Payload Logo
Medical Transcription

Medical Scribe vs. Transcriptionist: Which Career Is Right for You in 2025?

Author

Editorial Manager

Date Published

banner image of Medical Scribe vs. Transcriptionist: Which Career Is Right for You in 2025?

Technology, government requirements, and patient expectations are all changing roles at every level within the healthcare sector.

Medical scribes and transcriptionists are often underappreciated for their work in keeping records precise, of which is necessary.

Though automation is causing the lines between these professions to fade as we get to 2025, their fundamental distinctions are still sharp.

This article delves deeply into duties, abilities, pay, future developments, and—most of all—what position may fit you best should you consider a career in healthcare documentation.

A Medical Scribe Does What?

image of a medical scribe

Medical scribes serve as real-time documentation partners for doctors, nurses, and other providers. 

Their responsibilities go much beyond typing; they include:

- Real-time charting: Recording patient interactions, including histories, symptoms, physical examinations, and treatment plans.

- Organizing EHR: Ensuring compliance with billing code (e.g., ICD-10, CPT) by inputting data into Epic or Cerner electronic health records (EHRs).

- Workflow support: Preparing lab orders, imaging requests, and referrals to streamline provider tasks.

- Communication with Patients: Occasionally clarifying post-visit directives or responding to nonclinical inquiries.

While scribes in outpatient clinics may regularly develop long-term relationships with patients, those in emergency departments might handle several providers.

Skills Needed

- Knowledge of medicine: One must be well-versed in pharmacology, anatomy, and disease pathologies to analyze clinical jargon correctly.

- Fluency in technology: Using telehealth services, speech recognition software, and EHRs.

- Management of time: Prioritizing tasks during chaotic shifts; for  example, ER scribes, at times, may document 20+ patients daily.

- Soft skills: Empathy during challenging diagnosis, discretion with sensitive data, and collaboration.

Work Environment

1. Available in person: Clinics, hospitals, and specialty services ( for example, orthopedics).

2. Remote: Telehealth scribes listen to virtual visits via secure platforms, documenting in real time.

3. Shifts: They usually work full-time in a hospital, working weekends and evening hours.

Education and Certification

Most positions call for a high school diploma and on-the-job training. Candidates with competitive positions should have:

College-level coursework in biology, chemistry, or pre-med.

Training program from ScribeAmerica or certifications like the Certified Medical Scribe Specialist (CMSS).

Career Pathways

Many scribes see the role as a stepping stone leading to nursing, medical school, or physician assistant programs.

Earning and Career Prospects

Median salary:

Specialists in high-demand fields (such as oncology) earn up to $50,000 annually while others make $35,000 to $45,000.

Growth:

Driven by EHR requirements and provider exhaustion, the BLS forecast a 7% increase by 2032. Growing telehealth will add to the need for remote scribe services.

A Medical Transcriptionist Does What?

image of a medical trancriptionist

Medical transcriptionists convert audio recordings from providers into structured, error-free documents. Their workflow is more isolated and methodical. 

Their responsibilities include:

Transcription

Listening to voice recordings (e.g., dictations, surgical notes) and transcribing them into progress notes, discharge summaries, or operative reports.

Editing AI output

Fixing mistakes in artificial intelligence-generated drafts produced by tools such as Nuance Dragon.

Quality assurance Control

Ensuring compliance with HIPAA, formatting norms, and institutional rules.

Transcriptionists focus on accuracy and turnaround time, rarely engaging with patients or providers.

Skills Needed 

1. Typing Proficiency 

60–75 words per minute with near flawless precision.

2. Language Abilities

Expertise in grammar, punctuation, and medical terminology (e.g., differentiating "ileum" vs. "ilium").

3. Technology Tools

Knowledge of speech recognition systems, foot pedals, and transcription tools like Express Scribe.

4. Independence

Operating independently with little supervision.

Work Environment

- Remote work

90% of transcriptionists occasionally work from home as independent contractors or for outsourcing firms.

- Time constraints

Hospitals may require STAT reports within 2–4 hours, leading to irregular hours.

Education and Certification

High school graduates may apply for admission.

Qualifications

1. Registered Health Care Documentation Specialist (RHDS) for beginners.

2. For senior positions: Astext: Certified Healthcare Documentation Specialist

Career Pathways

Limited vertical expansion, but some shift into medical coding, auditing, or health information management.

Earning and Career Prospects

Median Salary: Annually, $30,000 to $50,000 is paid to expert editors.

Growth: The BLS expects AI automation to cause a 7% drop by 2032. Nevertheless, hybrid positions such as AI editors could help balance out losses.

Head-to-head comparison of major disparities in 2025

Work Surroundings

Medical scribes work in clinics, hospitals, or remotely (telehealth), often standing for hours in fast-paced environments.

Most transcriptionists are based remotely, working for agencies or freelancing with no medical presence. 

Patient Contact

Scribes have little interaction with patients (such as clarifying post-visit directives). Transcriptionists work entirely with audio files, with no contact with patients.

Documentation Timeticks

Scribes need to multitask for real-time test documentation. Transcriptionists concentrate on correctness rather than pace as they decode recordings after visits.

Systems

Scribes employ EHR systems (e.g., Epic) and AI voice assistants, blending technology and human oversight. Transcriptionists depend on speech recognition software like Dragon to edit AI-created documents.

Stress and Volume of Work

Scribing carries burnout dangers and is high-stress (e.g., ER shifts). Though isolation can be tiring, transcription is monotonous and usually self-paced.

Employment certainty

Because of the requirements for EHR, scribes enjoy a 7% rise (BLS). As artificial intelligence takes over manual labor, transcription jobs see a 7% fall.

Career growth

Scribes move into healthcare administration, medicine, or nursing. Transcriptionists pivot to coding, auditing, or specialty artificial intelligence editing jobs.

Education Costs

Scribes generally require little training, usually on the job. Transcriptionists could pay for certification courses.

Choose Medical Scribing for career advancement, clinical experience, and job flexibility. Select Transcription only if you value remote solitude and can adapt to AI editing. Scribing is the bolder, safer wager by 2025.

Pros and Cons

Medical Scribe

Pros:

Clinical Exposure: It is best for pre-med students or professionals seeking clinical experience.

Networking:  Direct access to physicians for mentorship and recommendation letters.

Dynamic Work: Great for people who hate monotony.

Cons:

Burnout Risk: Long hours standing in demanding locations may increase your risk of burnout.

Lower Initial Pay: Entry-level positions typically start at around $15/hour.

Medical Transcriptionist

Pros:

Flexibility: Ideal for parents or retired people since you can work from anywhere as a freelancer.

Low Pressure: No urgent deadlines unless working on STAT reports.

Remote Work:  Save time and money on commuting.

Cons:

Isolation: Minimal teamwork or social interaction.

Automation Threats: AI tools like DeepScribe reduce demand for manual transcription.

Future Trends Shaping Both Roles in 2025

1. Artificial Intelligence

Scribes: AI-powered ambient listening tools (e.g., Amazon's AWS for Health) will automate basic documentation. However, scribes will evolve into "AI trainers" who refine algorithms and handle complex cases.

Transcriptionists: Artificial intelligence voice recognition, such as Google's Medical Transcription API, will by 2025 substitute 40–50% of manual transcription. Transcriptionists will transition to "AI editors" who correct errors and ensure compliance.

2. Extension of Telehealth Services

Scribes: Virtual care will become mainstream, with an annual 20% rise in demand for remote scribes. Managing cross-platform EHR integrations and writing up e-visits will become scribes' duties.

Transcriptionists: Less impacted, though telehealth may reduce dictation volume as providers type notes during virtual visits.

3. Regulatory Changes

Adoption of ICD-11: By 2025, both positions will have to master revised coding criteria, hence elevating the need for detail-oriented professionals.

HIPAA Updates: Under more strict data protection standards, sophisticated encryption and privacy procedures instructions will be needed.

Who Should Pick What Job?

Select medical scribing, should you ...

Aim for clinical careers: Scribing offers unmatched patient care exposure, making it a golden treasure for medical school candidates.

Thrive Under Pressure: Scribing is gratifying if you enjoy problem-solving and quick, challenging situations.

Want Growth Opportunities: Scribes can become managers and trainers or enter medical administration with practice.

Medical transcription is your best alternative, should you …

Prefer Solitary Work: It is ideal for introverts who like quiet concentration and are free of distraction.

Need Flexibility: If you are a parent, a student, or someone with other businesses, freelance transcription fits you.

Have Editing Skills: AI editing roles could offer stable niche opportunities if you excel at detecting errors.

Which Career Is Better in 2025?

Medical Scribing Is the Clear Winner—Here's Why:

Doctors will always require human help to navigate AI tools and patient interactions.

Scribing opens doors to better clinical positions; paths for transcriptionists are passive.

On average, scribes make 10–20 percent more, with bonuses in in-demand specializations.

Scribes report higher engagement due to patient care involvement and team dynamics showing clear job satisfaction levels.

Exceptions: If you place a premium on independent work, hate patient contact, or are strapped for training time, transcription might be a good fit for you.

While transcriptionists have to niche down to survive automation, medical scribing will remain the safer, more dynamic choice for most by 2025. Evaluate your objectives, risk tolerance, and enthusiasm for healthcare to help you make the best decision.